Sign In Subscribe
Hero Banner

|

☰
  • Home
  • News
    • Top Stories
    • US
    • World
    • Elections Polls
    • Business
    • Tech
    • The Media
    • Genz
    • Public Policy
    • AI News
  • Voices
    • Hot Takes
    • Opinions
    • Proposals
    • Influencers
    • Pundits
    • Forum
  • Multimedia
  • Civic Education
  • Get Involved
  • About
    • Contributors
Donate
Home » AI’s Builders Asked for Brakes. Who Can Actually Apply Them?
Technology

AI’s Builders Asked for Brakes. Who Can Actually Apply Them?

Vaibhav SinhaBy Vaibhav SinhaSeptember 28, 20265 Comments8 Mins Read
Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp VKontakte Email
(Source: Unervi González, Unsplash)
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Pinterest Email

In early September, Dario Amodei of Anthropic published an essay to urge the slowdown of AI development. As the CEO of one of the leading AI companies, his call for more regulation is telling. Within days, competitors in the AI industry, such as Sam Altman of OpenAI and Elon Musk of xAI had endorsed his views. 

Soon after, on September 13th, House Speaker Mike Johnson argued that “If Congress just races in and does some sort of emergency session to try to regulate AI, we will lose the race to China, and that is a threat to every single American. So, we’ve got to have balance.”

President Trump, meanwhile, dismissed the call for a slowdown, arguing on Truth Social, “We already have tremendous CRIMINAL and REGULATORY power over these companies!” He went on to say: “There is a SICK conspiracy going on against AI and Data Centers, and the only one that is happy about it is China.”

It was a strange spectacle: the builders of a technology asking for restraint, and the government that could impose it refusing. If the companies building the most powerful AI systems want someone to set limits, who can?

The EU has set out a framework on AI regulation; in America, its industry leaders are calling for regulation, only for federal lawmakers to rebuff such attempts. 

Two Philosophies on AI Regulation

The European Union wrote the AI Act, which came into force in August 2024. The law applies to all 27 member states and divides AI by the different risks it poses. At the top of the hierarchy are AI uses that are banned, including social scoring by governments. Next, we have “high-risk” AI uses, such as systems that help to decide who gets hired, whether a customer is eligible for a loan, or whether a student should be offered admission into university. These systems are allowed, under certain rules and conditions, including transparency regarding how these AI programs are used.

AI-generated content, like Chatbots and LLMs (Large Language Models), carries lighter regulations to disclose what these tools are and how they are used. 

For the U.S., there is no equivalent federal law that governs AI. AI is still governed by older statutes on technology use, consumer protection, and copyright law. There is, however, a body of state law that is putting further scrutiny on how AI is used. 

Europe: The Rulebook & Slowdown

Europe was first to regulate via the EU AI Act. However, making rules is one thing; implementing them effectively is another.

Part of the problem is effective enforcement. By 2025, companies simply did not have the technology or set of standards needed to enforce key provisions. As a result, it became clear that key regulations, particularly for “high-risk” AI — which had greater reporting standards — would not be enforced on time.

A second problem is the structure of the EU. Under Article 70 of the act, each member state had until August 2nd, 2025, to establish standards and enforce the law. However, that deadline was not met, and each of the 27 member states moved at different speeds. Each member state also has its own limits and ability to effectively implement complex regulations. This is a common issue with EU regulatory frameworks, and the problem is also prevalent here.

Because of this issue, later in 2026, the European Commission made an amendment to the AI law, called the Digital Omnibus on AI. This law came into force in July of this year, as Regulation (EU) 2026/1744. The new timeline pushes obligations for stand-alone high-risk systems to Dec. 2, 2027.

It would be easy to read this as Europe losing its willingness to regulate AI; however, that misses a few things. 

Firstly, the omnibus also tightened the law. It added a ban on AI practices that generate non-consensual sexual imagery, including child sexual material. 

Second, the delay left the rules for general-purpose models untouched. These are the large systems, like ChatGPT and Claude, that sit under other products. Their providers have carried obligations since August 2025, and those whose models may pose “systemic risk” must notify the European AI Office. Using a banned practice can still cost a company up to 35 million euros or 7 percent of worldwide annual turnover.

Third, Brussels has already started to use these regulations. On Aug. 29, the AI Office sent its first formal requests for information: one set to developers of some of the most advanced models, and another to more than 30 companies on how they disclose their training data. 

How much further it will go is unknown, but the regulatory powers are real, and they are being used

America: Rulebooks Under Development 

In December 2025, President Trump signed Executive Order 14365, which makes it federal policy to pursue global AI dominance through a “minimally burdensome” national framework and to check state laws the administration considers excessive. The order directs the attorney general to create an AI Litigation Task Force to challenge them in court.

In July 2025, the Senate voted 99 to 1 to strip a 10-year moratorium on state AI laws from the president’s signature tax-and-spending bill. Opposition had come from both parties; Congress is not yet willing to federally regulate AI, but does not support stopping states from issuing their own.

With that vacuum, some states have decided to act. California’s SB 53, signed in September 2025 and in effect since January of this year, is aimed squarely at frontier AI like ChatGPT and Claude. It requires developers of the largest models to publish safety frameworks, report critical safety incidents to the state, and protect whistleblowers, with civil penalties of up to $1 million per violation. Colorado, on the other hand, targeted algorithmic discrimination in decisions about employment, housing, health care, lending, and education.

Colorado is also where the federal-state conflict became a lawsuit. In April of this year, Musk’s xAI sued to block the law, and the Justice Department joined the case on the company’s side, arguing that the law’s carve-out for diversity efforts violated equal protection. It was the first time this department had intervened in a case against a state AI law, and a court soon paused enforcement. In May, Colorado repealed and replaced the statute with a narrower one built on notice and recourse. People must be told when automated tools shape a decision about them, receive an explanation of an adverse outcome within 30 days, and then have a path to human review. The new law takes effect Jan. 1, 2027.

The result looks like a strange paradox: the binding American rules that exist were written at the state level, not in Washington D.C., and the federal government’s most visible effort has been to limit them. But supporters of the state-led approach see the system working roughly as designed. As part of the federalist design, a single state could serve as a laboratory for the rest of the country. California is now testing transparency rules for the largest models, and Colorado, after one false start, is testing notice and appeal rights for ordinary consumers.

Washington’s caution also reflects a real stake; American AI companies drew $285.9 billion in private investment in 2025, more than 20 times China’s total, according to Stanford’s AI Index. Those wary of regulation argue that lead is the country’s most important asset, and that rules written in haste could squander it: 

Image Source: HAI.Stanford

Side-by-Side Comparison

How the two systems differ:

What This Moment Reveals

Several tests are coming. Brussels must decide how far to take its first inquiries, and whether its talks with the labs produce anything binding. Congress must decide whether any safety bill can move before the election. And Europe’s high-risk rules arrive in December 2027, unless they are delayed again.

None of this settles which model is better. 

Europe is ahead on paper, but its delay and its uneven national rollout show how hard it is to turn a rulebook into practice across 27 countries, for a technology that moves faster than the standards which are meant to measure it. 

America is behind at the federal level, but some of its states are running experiments that the nation can learn from, in a market that leads the world in AI investment. 

What September exposed is a gap in readiness. When the people building AI asked for limits, Europe had some form of a regulatory system with jurisdiction, one that has begun to use its powers. America is still having a debate at the federal level, while states act to implement their own solutions.

Of course, this is an apples-to-oranges comparison. The U.S. is a nation, built under the framework of federalism, while the EU is a supranational organization, with 27 nation-states that have their own approach to regulation. 

Thus, comparing America to the EU might seem futile. The exercise, however, points to a larger divergence of approaches. We will see what approach lands best.

AI Artificial Intelligence EU
Share. Facebook Twitter Pinterest LinkedIn Tumblr WhatsApp Email
Previous ArticleAn Accessible History: Armenian Genocide Education Act
Next Article Sanctions for me, but not for thee: A case for increased UN sanctions on Israel
Vaibhav Sinha
  • X (Twitter)
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn

Vaibhav Sinha is a policy writer interested in finding actionable solutions to address public problems. He primarily writes about economics, politics, and foreign policy.

Related Posts

Robots Shouldn’t Kill

October 27, 2026

The Moon Landings: A Genuine Leap for Mankind

October 17, 2026

The Phone Ban’s Glaring Flaw

October 5, 2026

OpenAI Reveals Six Incidents That Are Sending the Tech World Spiraling

September 19, 2026

5 Comments

  1. Maya Balmanukyan on September 28, 2026 4:30 pm

    Really interesting article, Vaibhav! I liked the contrast you drew between AI developers calling for regulation and the federal government remaining hesitant to impose it. Your discussion of U.S. competitiveness with China also helped show why the issue is so complicated. I’d be curious to see whether a middle ground is possible where basic safeguards are created without slowing innovation too much. Great work.

    Reply
    • Vaibhav Sinha on October 4, 2026 4:36 am

      Thank you! I am also curious to see what middle ground we may land on, if at all.

      Reply
  2. Paige Hinton-Franciotti on September 30, 2026 5:32 pm

    As someone who is wary and avoidant of AI (as much as possible), I hope to see better federal regulations down the road. Just as AI technology is constantly evolving, so should the laws surrounding it.

    Reply
  3. Adrihanna Collins on October 2, 2026 12:21 pm

    This is an excellent article! I had no idea about the regulations on AI in the EU. Though it needs to be implemented carefully, I hope we see more regulations implemented soon, whether at the state or federal level.

    Reply
  4. Catherine Running on October 2, 2026 12:35 pm

    Very well written and researched! I think the fact that the creators of AI are pushing for regulation, and that other nations are already pursuing further regulation is a good signifier that this is something we need to be worrying more about. I think it’s really interesting to look at state vs. federal approach on this issue, and also looking at it through the lens of a sort of arms race. It’s so important to acknowledge the danger that this sort of race could cause with a technology that is still very unknown.

    Reply
Leave A Reply Cancel Reply

HOT TAKES

The Fall of the Cybertruck

November 7, 2026

Social Security’s Future is not Secure

October 19, 2026

My Body, My Choice of Vaccines

October 13, 2026

People Are Pushing Back On Mass Surveillance

October 10, 2026
Connect with Us
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
Don't Miss
Governance

It’s Time For Democrats To Get Serious

By Amaan BhimaniNovember 13, 20261

Democrats won big in the 2026 midterms with a momentous, full-force rebuke of President Donald…

Republicans Must Rebuild Voter Trust After a Costly 2026 Midterm Defeat

November 11, 2026

A PSA for Men: No One Is Coming To Save Us

November 10, 2026

When Medical Emergencies Interrupt Political Campaigns, Do Candidates Lose Ground to Their Opponents?

November 7, 2026
Subscribe to ONC's Newsletter

Get the latest balanced blend of news, opinion and policy proposals from OUR NATIONAL CONVERSATION. Published weekly.

Our National Conversation

Less Hate. More Debate.

HOME NEWS VOICES MULTIMEDIA GET INVOLVED ABOUT
Donate