This past weekend, I was able to enjoy a unique policy opportunity provided to me by my European Union course through the political science department at Susquehanna University. I participated in a multi-day European Union simulation at American University, where I represented the Hellenic Republic of Greece under the alter ego of Economy and Finance Minister, Kryiakos Pierrakakis. The context of the simulation was regarding the real-life EU proposal of the Digital Euro, which is a proposal backed by the European Central Bank (ECB) that allows citizens to use a digitalized version of the Euro for day to day costs. It also is made to strengthen the value of the Euro and reduce reliance on US stablecoins and financial institutions. Students from Susquehanna University, Elizabethtown College, American University, John Carroll University, University of Scranton, and James Madison University sat on the Council of Ministers and European Councils to debate individual proposals.
Washington, D.C. is no stranger to political spectacle. From the halls of Congress to the national news cycle, American politics has increasingly become defined by confrontation, partisan messaging, and the pursuit of political recognition. Yet, during my recent experience participating in this simulation in Washington, I was introduced to a different perspective on the responsibilities of government.
Representing Greece, I had the opportunity to experience firsthand the complexities of European policymaking, where competing national interests must be reconciled through negotiation and compromise. A national minister must equally weigh policy decisions of their nation with what the EU needs.
During my time, I was also able to meet with the Head of Economic and Commercial Affairs, Dionysios Protopapas, at the Greek Embassy in DC, where I got a firsthand Greek economic view of the Digital Euro and what Pierrakakis has done to support it through his current presidency of the EuroGroup.
The experience left me with a question worth considering:
What could the American federal government accomplish if it devoted less energy to political grandstanding and more to the difficult, often unrecognized work of governing?
What struck me most throughout the simulation was not the absence of disagreement, but the manner in which disagreement was approached. When debate slowed, when ministers challenged certain language in the proposal, or when motions to amend the proposal were introduced, there was a genuine concern for European well-being behind these interventions. Ministers were not looking for an opportunity to grandstand, gain political capital with insults, or drum up political stardom as we see in American legislative chambers. They were advocating for the interests of the countries they represented.
Every amendment carried a consideration of national priorities, economic consequences, and the broader implications for Europe. Even those who were representing countries outside of the Eurozone, which simply means they do not use the Euro as their national currency, sought additional provisions in the proposal. Even when negotiations entered varying levels of gridlock, the goal remained the same: to arrive at a proposal that could accommodate all EU nations’ interests while advancing a common European agenda that serves all.
It was a reminder of what real politics should be. Full of constructive debate, care, and a means of serving as an effective protector of citizens’ interests. It is an essential component we so sorely lack today on Capitol Hill and elsewhere.
We have seen that the American political scene is a major antithesis of what I was privy to in the simulation. It is the embodiment of political confrontation taking precedence over effective legislating. The 2013 government shutdown, stemming from disagreements over the Affordable Care Act, and the 35-day shutdown of 2018–2019, resulting from an impasse over border wall funding, show how political disagreements can escalate into institutional paralysis. In both instances, Washington’s political bourgeoisie and their inability to stop the bickering had detrimental and negative effects on the lives of federal employees, government services, and the American public sector.
This was proven in several reports that determined three government shutdowns before 2019 cost taxpayers $4 billion, furloughed 850,000 federal employees per day at the peak of the 2013 shutdown, and that in 2009, officials at the Bureau of Prisons estimated that delaying a contract for a prison facility had prevented them from locking in lower prices and resulted in about $5.4 million in additional costs. That is only a fraction of the unacceptable breaches of the American people’s good faith over the years, and a gross mishandling of our hard-earned tax dollars.
This growing habit of legislative proceedings becoming stages for partisan messaging is a dangerous pattern that has been normalized under both Republican and Democratic administrations throughout the years. Congressional hearings, intended to investigate, gather information, confirm officials, and allow accountability, have become opportunities for a gross level of theater. The American people were able to see this theater as recently as this September, when Senator Tommy Tuberville went on a tangent about ‘Furries’ and the risks to aviation that the community posed. His claims were completely unsubstantiated and had no weight. He only sought to uphold culture wars by tying it into a larger tangent about transgenderism.
That is not to suggest that confrontation or strong political advocacy has no place in American democracy. Quite the contrary, our country was built on that sentiment and so much more. We cannot have a free society without free discourse. The distinction, however, lies in whether or not that discourse is serious, respectful, and willing to compromise where needed.
That distinction is worth considering in today’s disheveled and broken American political landscape. Hopefully, the United States and its politicians will one day more closely appreciate the beauty and passion presented within the EU’s legislative and governmental framework.
Acknowledgement: The opinions expressed in this article are those of the individual author, not necessarily Our National Conversation as a whole.
